Game Reviews in Different Media
In
this report I will be comparing two reviews of Lightning Returns: Final Fantasy
XIII. I will cover 7 topics; Genre, Target Audience, Narrative, Characters,
Gameplay, Platforms and any personal recommendations from the reviewer. At the
end of the report I will give an overall conclusion on how a review can change
over different Medias. I will be comparing the Official XBOX Magazine article
(Official XBOX Magazine, March 2014, pg. 69, Heidi Kemps) and the IGN YouTube
review of Lightning Returns: Final Fantasy XIII.
Genre
Both
of the reviews briefly mentioned the genre of the game to be open world but
there was very little detail on this point. The XBOX Magazine article said more
on this topic and described the game as an open-world action-adventure RPG
game.
Target Audience
Neither
of the two reviewers mentioned the game’s target audience. This suggests that
they either did not know who the game was aimed at or they didn’t think it was
relevant to their review of the game.
Narrative
Again,
the Official XBOX Magazine article has a lot more textual detail on this topic.
They talk about how the logic of the plot is often contradicted by the
behaviour of some characters, except when it is convenient to the flow of
events. They also talk about how there is no specific order to the tasks, and
that the plot is complex and difficult to follow. The IGN video review does not
have too much detail on this subject. It mainly repeats a lot of the things
covered by the XBOX magazine review but does mention that it “Stumbles in its
story telling” and “ends in a muddled and totally inconsistent whimper”.
This is a very similar point to the one from the XBOX magazine, saying
that the plot was complex and difficult to follow, but it is made in a harsher
way than in the magazine.
Characters
Both
reviews went in to a fair amount of detail on the characters in the game. They
both speak mostly about the main protagonist, Lightning, and they both mention
that she is unlikeable and shows a “disinterested attitude towards the people
she is saving” This connotes that Lightning is a boring character and is not
easily likeable. Again the article from the Official XBOX Magazine goes in to
more detail on one specific character and very little is mentioned about the
other characters in the game whereas the IGN video review speaks about more
characters but in less detail. The IGN video review says that the game has
forgotten why fans of the series liked the characters, and that most of the
characters have lost their personalities. He goes on to say that there is no
life left in the characters, which makes the player care less for these
characters when playing through the game.
Gameplay
Gameplay
is the most detailed section in both reviews. Their reviews of the gameplay are
separated in to different sections covering the battle system, the world, and
the performance of the game. Both the Official XBOX article and the IGN video
review say that the new battle system and world is a good change for the game
and is refreshing for the player. The IGN reviewer said that using the new
battle system was the highlight of his 30 hours play through of the game.
The XBOX reviewer said that Lightning Returns Final Fantasy XIII “Tosses
the first 2 games out of the window and rebuilds itself as a unique
open-world/RPG hybrid game”. This suggests that this game has changed
everything from the older games and made a lot of changes since the original.
The reviewers have different views on the world design with one saying it is
one of the best parts of the game and the other saying that the world is boring
and forgettable. This suggests that there are some biased opinions and remarks
in these reviews based on the reviewer’s personal preferences. Yet again there
is a lot more detail in the Official XBOX Magazine article but this article
does not give much visual aid for the reader to help them understand what they
are trying to say. The use of visual aids is a lot more common in the video
review as it has game footage playing in the background, which relates to the
points being made by the reviewer.
Both of the reviewers make the same point about there being a lot of repetitive
side quests that are nearly all the same, but with different characters.
However, the combat system somewhat distracts from the issues with the games
design. Another point made by both of the reviewers is about the time limit set
on the game. The game has a time limit, meaning the player cannot complete all
of the quests in one play through. This is a problem for the reviewers as they
say that it cuts the gameplay short and limits what the player can do.
Platforms
Another
topic that was very quickly talked about was the platform on which they
reviewed the game. Official XBOX Magazine tested it on XBOX 360, with this
being clearly stated on the introduction to the review, and the IGN video
review did not say which console he played the game on. However, because it was
a video review the UI of the game showed the PlayStation buttons for the moves.
This means that the viewer would know that the game was reviewed on PlayStation
though they may not know which PlayStation console specifically. Official XBOX
Magazine has to test their games on XBOX consoles because they are publishing
for the XBOX community. This means that their reviews will be based completely
on the XBOX versions of the game, instead of having the reviewer test the game
on multiple platforms. This gives an opinion of the game from one perspective,
as some bugs or flaws in the game may be console specific. A crash that happens
at one specific part of the game every time the player goes there may not
happen on every platform. This means the review from someone that tested
the game on one console may differ dramatically from a review from the same
game on a different console.
Personal recommendations from the reviewer
Both
of the reviewers give a brief recommendation of the game stating their rating
of the game out of 10 and giving a summary of their review in a few sentences.
Both of the reviewers give the game a 7/10 despite their reviews mainly
consisting of negative comments on different parts of the game. They both say
that the new combat system and the aesthetics of the game make it worth the purchase.
In their recommendations they try to give a more positive look at their
review with the XBOX Magazine article saying that it shows potential for future
Final Fantasy games, with Square Enix trying a lot of new things. The IGN video
review says that it is a good game, mainly because of the combat system and the
well-designed world, but the characters are not memorable, its tone is
inconsistent and the story is lacklustre. This shows that both reviewers are
trying to give an overview of the positive and negative points in their final
few paragraphs to give the viewer/reader a summary of what they covered in
their review. This gives a summary of the main points of their review without
going in to much detail and ends their reviews with their final thoughts on the
game.
Conclusion
In
conclusion the magazine article from the Official XBOX Magazine gave a lot more
detail on each of the subjects with very little in visual examples from the
game. The reviewer spoke in more depth on all of the topics and gave a more
detailed review of the game itself. However, the IGN video review had a lot
more visual evidence to back up their points, which further helps the viewer to
understand what he is trying to say. The Official XBOX Magazine article does
have some screenshots of the game to try and illustrate some of its points but
they do not go in to much detail on the images. This shows that a video review
is more focused on explaining the gameplay with some evidence from the game
itself to support their points whereas the magazine review is purely making a
point and has references to parts in the game that help support their points.
Both of the reviewers gave the game a 7/10 rating at the end
of their review. This shows that although they may have different methods of
reviewing the games, they still get a relatively similar rating for the game.
This is also evident in the content of the reviews as both reviewers made very
similar points throughout but explained them in different ways and used
different methods to evidence those points.
There seemed to be more points from the perspective of fans
of the older Final Fantasy games in the IGN review, as he mentioned that the
older characters have lost their personalities and seem a lot more lifeless
than in previous games.
Overall, both reviewers make very similar points and both
give the game the same rating, but they use different methods of evidencing
their points. There are also some personal views in the reviews, but these
views are relevant to the larger audience that they are targeting.
No comments:
Post a Comment